Skip to main content

Forty-eight hours in the making

The pizzas at Ember & Dough in Shadyside take ninety seconds to bake, but the dough behind them has been resting for two days.

By Maria Kessler3 min read

Share on Facebook
Tiled dome pizza oven with a log fire burning inside

Featured in this story

Ember & Dough Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Shadyside

View the listing
Tiled dome pizza oven with a log fire burning inside

A Margherita at Ember & Dough Pizza takes about ninety seconds to bake. The dough that goes into it takes forty-eight hours. That gap, between the speed of the oven and the patience of the kitchen, is the story of this Shadyside restaurant, which has been firing pies since 1997.

Marco mixes the dough himself, two days before it is needed. Flour, water, salt and a tiny amount of yeast go into a large mixer, and then the dough rests in the cooler under a lid. Nothing is added to speed it along. During those two days the dough slowly ferments, developing a mild tang and a texture that bubbles and chars in a way a fast dough does not.

The oven that never quite cools

The oven is a domed brick structure at the back of the dining room, and it is the room's focal point. It is fed with hardwood and held close to nine hundred degrees. Marco says he lights it at ten each morning, and by the time the first lunch order arrives the floor of the oven is ready.

A pizza goes in on a long wooden peel. The pizzaiolo turns it once, after about forty seconds, so that the crust blisters evenly. At ninety seconds the pie comes out with a soft, puffed edge, a few leopard-like spots of char and a centre that is still slightly wet. This is the Neapolitan style, and it is meant to be eaten with a knife and fork or folded quickly by hand.

The menu is short. A Margherita, a pie with sausage and peppers, a white pie with ricotta and garlic, and a seasonal special that changes monthly. Marco resists adding more. He says the more toppings a pizza carries, the less the dough matters, and the dough is the thing he wants people to taste.

A dining room run by Lena

Marco's wife Lena runs the front of the house. She greets people, assigns tables and keeps a short wine list of Italian bottles that she tastes herself before ordering. She also keeps the reservation book, in pencil, on a shelf by the door. Weekend tables fill a few days ahead, so booking is wise, and the restaurant is closed on Mondays.

On weekdays between eleven-thirty and two, the restaurant sells slices with a small salad, which suits office workers from the nearby buildings. The slices are cut from pies baked a few minutes earlier, and the crust stays crisp enough to hold its shape in the hand.

A long table at the back seats parties of eight to twelve and is popular for birthdays. Lena says the best nights are the ones when a table of strangers ends up sharing a pie, but she is careful not to push it.

Why the wait matters

I asked Marco whether the two-day rest was really necessary. He shrugged and said you could make a decent pizza in four hours. Then he handed me a small piece of crust from each batch, one aged for a day and one for two. The difference was easy to taste. The longer one was lighter, with a faint sourness and a deeper colour.

It is a small detail, and most diners will never think about it. But it explains why the restaurant has stayed busy for more than twenty years in a neighbourhood with plenty of competition. Good pizza is a matter of time as much as heat.

If you go, order the Margherita first. It is the simplest pie on the menu and the best test of the kitchen. Then, if you can, ask Marco which day the dough was mixed. He will know.

Maria Kessler writes about local businesses for the Demo City directory.

In this story

  • Ember & Dough Pizza

    Wood-fired pizza from dough that rests for 48 hours

    Pizza restaurant · Shadyside

  • Bright cafe bar with grinders, brewers and a large indoor tree by tall windows
    Local story

    The roaster who knows every regular's order

    At Incline Roasters on the South Side, Dana roasts the beans in the back room and remembers the drink each customer wants before they reach the counter.

    About Incline Roasters · South Side

  • Auto repair workshop with red two-post lifts and a car being serviced
    Local story

    The brake shop on the steepest street

    Liberty Garage on Mount Washington sees more brake jobs than anything else, because the neighbourhood's hills punish pads and rotors.

    About Liberty Garage · Mount Washington

  • Roses, ranunculus and delphinium in zinc buckets outside a flower shop
    Local story

    Flowers from twenty miles away

    Bloom & Branch in Lawrenceville buys nearly everything from growers within twenty miles, which means the shop's cooler follows the seasons.

    About Bloom & Branch Florist · Lawrenceville